25+ Easy Bake Sale Ideas that Actually Sell
Looking for treats that are cute, effortless and always sell well? These easy bake sale ideas include cookies, brownies, bars, cupcakes, and a few colorful surprises. Most are simple to portion ahead of time, so you can spend less time packaging and more time enjoying the event.
Brownie Mix Brookies
Why choose between cookies and brownies when you can have both? These brookies bring two familiar favorites together in one easy-to-serve treat. Plus, they use a brownie mix so you don’t have to measure a bunch of individual ingredients.
Frosted Funfetti Cake Mix Cookies
Colorful sprinkles and frosting make these cookies stand out on a bake sale table. Starting with a cake mix keeps the prep easy, too.
Sheet Pan Rice Krispie Treats
A sheet pan makes it easy to prepare a big batch and cut it into individual squares. These classic treats are a great choice when you need plenty of portions without a lot of fuss.
Banana Pudding Cupcakes
These cupcakes turn the flavors of banana pudding into a handheld dessert. They’re a fun pick for anyone looking for something beyond the usual chocolate and vanilla.
M&M Cookie Bars
Bright candy pieces make these cookie bars hard to miss. Cut them into squares for an easy treat that shoppers can carry away.
Lemon Cake Mix Whoopie Pies
Soft lemon cookies with a sweet filling give these whoopie pies a little something extra. Their sunny flavor adds a fresh option to a table full of chocolate treats.
Brownies with Ganache and Sprinkles
A layer of ganache and a scattering of sprinkles make these brownies look ready for a celebration. Slice them into neat squares for a rich, individually portioned treat.
Churro Cookie Cups
These little cookie cups bring cinnamon sugar flavor to the bake sale. Their small size makes them especially tempting for someone who wants just a bite or two.
Fluffernutter Rice Krispie Treats
Peanut butter and marshmallow give these Rice Krispie treats a fun twist on the classic. Package them separately and label the peanut ingredient clearly.
Neapolitan Cake Mix Cookies
Chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry flavors make these cookies as fun to look at as they are to eat. They bring plenty of color to the table with the convenience of a cake mix recipe.
Oreo M&M Blondies
Oreos and M&Ms make these blondies an eye-catching choice for cookie lovers. Cut them into squares to show off the mix-ins in every piece.
Funfetti Cake Pops
Cake pops feel like a special treat, and their small size makes them easy to grab. The funfetti flavor and cheerful look fit right in at a bake sale.
S’mores Cake Mix Cookie Bars
Chocolate, graham crackers, and marshmallows give these cookie bars all the appeal of s’mores. They’re a great way to offer that familiar flavor in a sliceable dessert.
Strawberry Cake Mix Whoopie Pies
These pink whoopie pies add a bright pop of color between the brownies and bars. Their soft cookies and filling make each one feel like a complete little dessert.
Nut Free Puppy Chow
Portion this sweet, crunchy snack into individual bags or cups for an easy grab-and-go option. It’s a nice change of pace for shoppers who want something to nibble rather than a baked dessert.
S’mores Cake Mix Cookies
Top the table with one more crowd-pleasing combination of chocolate, graham crackers, and marshmallow. These cookies offer s’mores flavor in a portion that’s easy to pick up and take home.
Sheet Pan Red Velvet Brownies
The deep red color gives these brownies instant visual appeal. A sheet pan batch also makes it simple to cut enough pieces for a crowd.
Homemade Frosted Sugar Cookies
A frosted sugar cookie is a bake sale classic for good reason. These look pretty on display and are easy to package one at a time.
Salted Caramel Rice Krispie Treats
Salted caramel gives familiar Rice Krispie treats a richer flavor. They’re an easy choice when you want a no-bake option that still feels a little special.
Mini S’mores Bites
These mini cupcakes pack the flavors of a campfire favorite into a small treat. Their size makes it easy for shoppers to pick one up alongside another dessert.
Peach Pie Sugar Cookie Bars
Peach pie flavor meets a sliceable sugar cookie bar in this fruity option. These bring a welcome change from the chocolate-heavy bake sale favorites.
Frosted Red Velvet Cake Mix Cookies
With their rich color and frosting, these cookies make a striking addition to the table. The cake mix base also makes them approachable when you’re baking several recipes.
M&M Oreo Brownies
These brownies combine chocolate with two colorful, familiar mix-ins. They’re an especially fun pick if you want a brownie that catches someone’s eye right away.
Mini M&M Cookie Cups
Small cookie cups dotted with M&Ms make a cheerful bite-sized treat. Set them out in individual portions or package a few together.
M&M Oreo Rice Krispie Treats
This version dresses up classic Rice Krispie treats with Oreos and colorful M&Ms. The mix-ins make each square look a little different and especially fun to display.
Lemon Lavender Shortbread Cookies
These shortbread cookies offer a more delicate flavor for shoppers who want something less sweet. Their lemon and lavender pairing adds variety to the cookie selection.
Cherry Pie Sugar Cookie Bars
Cherry pie flavor gives these sugar cookie bars a fruity finish. Slice them into squares for a treat that’s easy to serve without cutting a whole pie.
A bake sale is a chance to share something homemade while supporting a good cause, and your desserts don’t have to be complicated to make an impression. These easy bake sale ideas offer plenty of inspiration, whether you love baking cookies, decorating cupcakes, or keeping things simple with a batch of bars. When looking for bake sale items that sell, you can’t go wrong with this list.
